Showing posts with label Washington Street. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Washington Street. Show all posts

Monday, November 16, 2026

The Pilgrim's regress

The Pilgrim Theatre, Washington Street, Boston, c.1959.
Pilgrim Theatre, new signage, 1949.
In the opening shot of the 1978 film The Brink's Job, small-time crook Tony Pino (Peter Falk) puffs on his cigar and proceeds down a narrow, dark alley to begin to lay his deep, dark plans for what would become Boston's Great Brink's Robbery of 1950. The alley's vanishing point reveals a sliver of the iconic neon marquee of the Pilgrim Theatre that stood on Washington Street at the time, a year after it got its name. 
This shot is very telling about the regressive demise this great building would suffer, in its fall from theatrical grace as Gordon's Olympia Theatre, to notoriety as an X-rated adult moviehouse, to demolition.

Designed by Clarence Blackall, architect of Boston's Emerson Colonial, Wilbur and Wang Theatres and Tremont Temple Baptist Church, Gordon's Olympia was built in 1915 within an existing 1891 office building, a gracefully slender, soaring neoclassical structure crowned and introduced by arches: the wide street-level entry arch to the theater, lettered with its name on the frieze, and the smaller crest-topped "hump" arch crowning the clock, which was bearded below by a leafy festoon relief. 

The vertical window-bank – an early prototype for modern office fenestration from the 1950s forward – and the entry arch innovatively integrated block-letter branding into their recesses: "HIGH CLASS" along the top of the windows, "CONTINUOUS PERFORMANCES" vertically lettered on their left and right, and "10¢" at either end of the "GORDON'S OLYMPIA" sign on the entry arch. 

Owner Nathan H. Gordon of Olympia Theatres, Inc., was a motion picture executive who emigrated from Vilna in the Russian Empire to Connecticut at age 18, opened Worcester's first theater in 1906, and became New England's largest operator of motion picture and vaudeville theaters. With that he founded and chaired Olympia Theatres, Inc., in 1912. In this capacity Gordon built and operated 38 motion picture theaters throughout New England, including the Gordon's Olympia houses in Scollay Square and at 658 Washington Street.

The Washington Street theater's narrow façade hardly belied its spacious hall, which seated
 2,500 in an orchestra, two brass-railed balconies, and 14 brass-railed loges. Its wide proscenium arch allowed all a good view. Its vault ensured good acoustics. Its decorative scheme of festoons and frescoes bore Blackall's trademark of classic theatrical elegance.

Gordon's Olympia on Washington Street promoted its films with splashy signs and giant illustrations, enticing streetwalkers to come on in, pay their ten cents, and lose themselves in the la-la land of Hollywood. Nathan H. Gordon's on-the-side role as a co-founder of t
he Gordon-Mayer Theatrical Company with Louis Mayer of MGM fame ensured a wider distribution of pictures at Gordon's numerous theaters.

Pilgrim Theatre, Boston, summer of 1959.
After changing multiple hands and being known by multiple names, the theater was rechristened the Pilgrim in 1949 as a second-run moviehouse. It received a vertically free-hanging neon sign down its soaring façade and the double gatefold marquee topped by its name in neon cursive writing that would landmark it for the next four decades, first as a second-run moviehouse...

.
Pilgrim Theatre, Boston, 1974.
..and 
then as an X-rated adult moviehouse by the late 1960s, when its immediate area degenerated into the Combat Zone, so called because of all the soldiers and sailors on leave from combat that flocked to this red-light district for the quick sexual thrills of porn movies, peep shows, burlesque and strip-tease acts, prostitutes, adult book stores, sex shops, and more. Porn blockbusters like Deep Throat and The Devil in Miss Jones packed them in.
Pilgrim Theatre, Boston, 1970s.
The Pilgrim's notoriety peaked in 1974 when U.S. Rep. Wilbur Mills appeared on stage there with Argentine stripper Annabel Batistella, aka Fanne Foxe, who had a two-week engagement there and said Mills had written a film, It's Not Burlesque, exclusively for her. 
“I'm going to make a movie star out of her," he told The New York Times. "She's better than Gypsy Rose Lee.” Naturally, his political downfall followed.

Pilgrim Theater and abutters, Boston, 1985.
The downfall of the Pilgrim itself was eminent when Boston Mayor Thomas M. Menino supported theater owner W. Kevin Fitzgerald's aim to demolish the theatre and its contiguous block (including the Naked I bar) for a parking lot followed by future new development, as part of Menino's efforts to "zone out" the Combat Zone.

The Pilgrim Theatre and vicinity, Boston, 1980s.
Shocked at the very idea of destroying a historic theater designed by Boston's premier theater architect, I wrote two columns in The Boston TAB opposing the Pilgrim's destruction, before and after its 1996 demolition. I mentioned that the Globe Theatre down the street had become a successful Chinese restaurant, so the Pilgrim could have been reused in a similar way.

Soon I got a letter from Fitz-Inn Auto Parks, which made it clear who the writer was and why he was writing to me. Fitzgerald rebutted me as follows: "Having restored the Liberty Tree Block and Jacob Wirth Restaurant, and having kept pace with 19 Stuart Street, I believe I know a bit more about the restoration of buildings than you. It is easy for you to spend other people's money to determine how long a building must stay empty waiting for occupancy; however, my economics do not allow me the luxuries that you have as an innocent bystander. Quite simply, it is the economics, stupid. (To use your words.)"

Demolition of the Pilgrim Theatre and neighboring buildings, 1996.
His last sentences were responding to the final ones of second column: "It's not the economy, stupid. It's all in how you look at things." And he had said that the Pilgrim and its neighboring buildings were "not economically viable" due to the bad raps they had acquired for their years of X-rated use, and that simply renovating the Pilgrim on spec would have required a costly upgrade past the outmoded fire codes that had grandfathered in it during its adult movie phase. And the later bankruptcy of Fitzgerald's real estate development business, which entailed selling off Jacob Wirth in 2018 to defray the court costs of his divorce, lent a bit more credence to his concerns about economics.

The Pilgrim Theatre site today (660 Washington Street Apartments).
Still, history is the highest judge of all, and the Pilgrim's standing as a Blackall theater on an architectural par with his operating theaters made it worth the wait for the type of renovation that reimagined the Paramount Theatre as the Emerson Paramount Center, the B.F. Keith/Savoy Theatre as the Citizens Opera House, the Modern Theatre as a Suffolk University venue, the Globe Theatre as the Empire Garden, and the Saxon Theatre as the Emerson Cutler Majestic Theatre. But the antsy Fitzgerald clearly came from a capitalist family hell-bent on owning and profiting from as much prime real estate ASAP.

Liberty Tree Block (1850, David Sears), Washington & Essex Streets, Boston.















He restored the Liberty Tree Block (above) and Jacob Wirth (right) primarily because they were landmarked, and he couldn't tear them down (as his father had wanted to do with Jacob Wirth in 1975). But now they look very lonely without the whole blocks that had enriched their character, contributed to Boston's own "Great White Way," and were far finer in detail, variety, and early history than the bland 660 Washington Street Apartments tower and parking facility that replaced the Pilgrim and its neighbors, draining that corner of the neighborhood of the historical and cultural character that it once had before the Combat Zone, and that it was capable of recapturing, with imagination, determination, and renovation.

To be continued...


Sources:

"A Few Tales from the Pilgrim...", This Dazzling Time, June 29, 2014, https://donstradley.blogspot.com/2014/06/a-few-tales-from-pilgrim.html

"Gordon's Olympia Theatre (Boston)," Wikipedia, last edited on 29 July 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gordon's_Olympia_Theatre_(Boston)

"Jacob Wirth Restaurant," Wikipedia, last edited on 2 September 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jacob_Wirth_Restaurant

Krumpholz, Karl Christian, "The Pilgrim Theatre,"
karlchristiankrumpholz
,
Instagram, May 20, 2025, https://www.instagram.com/p/DJ5BDIbSPbx/

"Liberty Tree Block // 1850," Buildings of New England, February 16, 2025, https://buildingsofnewengland.com/2025/02/16/liberty-tree-block-1850/

McGuinness, Dylan, "The History of Jacob Wirth Co.", The Boston Globe, January 18, 2018, https://www.bostonglobe.com/metro/2018/01/18/the-history-jacob-wirth/aqA8c6HTwoHMpBoiS8MyfJ/story.html?event=event12

"Mills Does a Walk-on With Stripper," The New York Times, December 2, 1974, https://www.nytimes.com/1974/12/02/archives/mills-does-a-walkon-with-stripper-where-are-you.html

"Nathan J. Gordon," Wikipedia, last edited on 16 October 2024, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nathan_H._Gordon

Peplum TV, "At the movies...", Peplum, October 2, 2026, https://www.peplumtv.com/2026/10/at-movies.html

"Wilbur Mills," Wikipedia, last edited on 3 October 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wilbur_Mills