Sunday, November 15, 2026

Boston's last leg of 'urban renewal'

Whenever a mammoth "modern" building so unlike its abutters, neighbors and predecessors in form, style and appearance grabs my attention without striking my fancy, all that piques my interest about it is what building, block, street or neighborhood it replaced.

Boston's State Transportation Building, an early 1980s Goody, Clancy & Associates design that usurped an entire block, and then some, on and off Stuart Street and bulldozed away a good century and a half of Boston history, is such a building. Touted at the time as a convenient consolidation of state transportation agencies and a renewal of Boston's Theatre District with a retail arcade, food-court atrium and pedestrian mall providing "liveliness both day and evening," in Marvin Goody's words to The Boston Globe, its swoopy, curvy, streamlined brick façade certainly expressed those intentions. It also forced us to forget that a historic theatre was torn down for it, along with other milestones in Boston architecture, culture and history.

As the last leg of the "urban renewal" of Boston that wiped out whole streets and districts, regardless of what historical and cultural curiosities they contained, for major government centers or central arteries – that is, destroyed a village in order to "save" it – the State Transportation Building changed the face of Stuart Street and vicinity from a diverse collection of styles, eras and enterprises to one bland behemoth of bureaucracy and business. 
Scollay Square and West End clearances, 1963.
Courtesy of the Northeastern University Library.
Just as Government Center had done to Scollay Square. Just as Charles River Park had done to the West End. Just as the Herald's printing plant and other industrial development had done to the South End's "New York streets" district. And just as the Central Artery, the Massachusetts Turnpike, and the aborted I-695 "Inner Belt" highway had done to countless neighborhoods in their paths.


Let us pause and ponder what we lost when Stuart Street was sterilized by the State:

Carver Street

Edgar Allan Poe birthplace (left), c.1910.
Carver Street, which the State Transportation Building obliterated except for a trickle of a service lane and a plaque marking the site of the birthplace of mystery/horror writer Edgar Allan Poe, had a few early 19th-century brick houses left from the period of Poe's birth in 1809. Poe was born here to thespian parents, David and Eliza Poe, who lived here from 1806 to 1809 and acted in such local productions as Thomas Merton's Speed the Plough and Shakespeare's Hamlet, Macbeth and King Lear. Poe's house itself went down in 1959 for a parking lot expansion for the electrical power plant of Boston Edison (now Eversource). But three of its contemporaries still stood, preserving a remnant of the narrow, spooky alley the master of the macabre was born in.

12-14 Carver Street ("The Settlement House"), c.1903.
One of these turn-of-the-19th-century rowhouses had been a settlement house by 1903, and later housed two of Boston's leading gay bars, the Twelve Carver Bar and Herbie's Ramrod Room, a decade before the 1969 police raid on the Stonewall Inn in New York brought fresh energy into the LGBTQ+ rights movement. Twelve Carver, which opened in 1958, became a main venue for local gay performers yet welcomed people of all preferences and backgrounds, from truck-drivers to Harvard students. But that didn't stop cynical citizens and local pols from going after it. City Councilor Fred Langone wanted the bar done over, insisting that “we will be better off without these incubators of homosexuality and indecency… We will uproot this cancer in one area of the city.” Twelve Carver thus became an early safe, supportive space for Boston’s then-persecuted LGBTQ+ community until Freddy got his wishes when the bulldozers came. Five years prior, Twelve Carver was publicized by Gay Community News as follows: "Cupids and minors, the '30s decor is original... older, local crowd; funny, friendly bartender. Occasional live entertainment, no organized dancing..."leather" bar upstairs, see Herbie's Ramrod Room (a rose by any other name)."

Herbie's Ramrod Room, upstairs at 12 Carver St., Boston, in 1975.
Herbie's Ramrod Room was thus described in the same 1974 issue of Gay Community News: "One flight up to leather and Levis and wall-to-wall beefcake photos...slave bracelets in sterling, papier-maché lumberjacks behind the bar, and a dimpling bar-lad to boot...manacles optional. One pool table, one jukebox, but lots of pretzels and popcorn on the bar."

"Courtyard of Ola's Restaurant, with Diners, Carver Street," photographed by Nishan Bichajian, 1956.
Twelve Carver's next-door neighbor at No. 14 housed an upper-scale alternative to snacks at Herbie's: Ola. Believed to be Boston's first Norwegian restaurant, Ola was established by a visionary Norwegian architect during the Great Depression, who obviously wasn't afraid of a tanking economy, and even saw it as an opportunity to try a new enterprise Boston had seen little of before. Approachable 
through an archway with a cast-iron gate lavished with scrolled lancets and quatrefoils, its outdoor courtyard looked as if it were straight out of Beacon Hill, in the brick-walled hidden garden intimacy that was perfect for enjoying al fresco dining with Ola's legendary Norwegian coffee and smorgasbord table. It made you want to say "Skol!" with total gusto. (No public records indicate the occupants of 16 Carver St.)

While the last remnants of Carver Street were being snuffed out, my father visited their demolition site, salvaged a few bricks and a roof-slate shingle from the rubble, engraved "CARVER STREET" in the slate in his architect's long-hand, and placed the salvages in our backyard garden as a memorial to one of the few remaining turn-of-the-19th-century Boston streets in Downtown Crossing/Park Square, where Federal brick rowhouse architecture took shape concurrently with Beacon Hill, where a literary icon was born, where Scandinavian cuisine took root in Boston, and where LGBTQ+ culture and community sprouted before Stonewall as a generator of the gay rights movement that culminated in the 2003 Supreme Court ruling legalizing same-sex marriage in Massachusetts, Goodridge v. Department of Public Health, and ultimately legalizing it nationally in Obergefell vs. Hodges in 2015.

Hillbilly Ranch

This was on Eliot Street, another street the State Transportation Building obliterated. Sporting the Route 66 "Googie" appeal of a 1920s-30s diner, but with wild-west-style stockade-fence décor and tree-log lettering signage to signify the kind of music and culture inside, the Hillbilly Ranch was the brainchild of Italian immigrant Frank Sevalini, who had opened an Italian restaurant at Stuart and Carver streets in the 1940s. 
Deciding he wanted something different, he followed his friend's counsel to open Boston's only musical venue dedicated solely to country, western, bluegrass and mountain music. 

Spruced up with wood-paneled walls and wagon-wheel light fixtures for thematic consistency, the Hillbilly Ranch attracted top country acts such as Bill Monroe & The Bluegrass Boys, Don Stover, The Lilly Brothers, Tex Logan, Tex Ritter, the Bayou Boys, Sleepy LaBeef, and even Johnny Cash and Loretta Lynn.

Bob and Grace French and the Rainbow Valley Boys at the Hillbilly Ranch, 1950s
Because the Ranch was Boston's only venue dedicated to country, western and bluegrass music, soldiers and sailors on leave, southerners who had migrated north, and others yearning for that down-home fare packed the Ranch nightly. The southern twang they were treated to influenced the folk revivals of the '60s and '70s with a musical style atypical of Boston, where jazz clubs and Irish pubs were prevalent. This made the Hillbilly Ranch as much of an alternative social magnet for "outsiders" as the gay bars down the street. Boston's sole "country club" met its demise when eminent domain closed its curtain.

Union Oyster House

The legendary seafood restaurant, operating in Boston's Blackstone Block since 1826 and counting, opened a satellite operation on Stuart Street in 1932 in a Victorian rowhouse dating from 1844 plus two abutting historic rowhouses. This trio presented a rich panoply of styles – Boston Granite, Victorian Brick, French Second Empire – that was unusual for a single eating place.

That threesome gave this Union Oyster House a European flavor. Having the Plymouth Theatre, later the Gary movie theater, as its next-door neighbor over the years was another advantage: one could enjoy a hearty dinner of freshly shucked oysters or lobster before attending a play or movie right next door, or a country-and-western or bluegrass performance at the Hillbilly Ranch nearby.

Unfortunately, this restaurant met with two counts of painful fate, as if destined to be shucked off one day. On February 7, 1949, three armed men broke into it through a fire door, held its employees at gunpoint, broke open its cash safe, and made off with $300. In 1961, a fire damaged this location, and it closed in 1962, but somehow retained its sign until the area was cleared.

Plymouth Theatre

Designed by Clarence Blackall on an architectural par with his Colonial, Wilbur and Wang Theatres and Tremont Temple Baptist Church, the Plymouth Theatre opened on September 23, 1911, with a repertoire of Irish drama by the Abbey Theatre Company of Dublin to start their first American tour, including John Millington Synge's The Playboy of the Western World. In attendance were Abbey Theatre founders William Butler Yeats and Lady Gregory, Rose Fitzgerald Kennedy, Isabella Stewart Gardner, and Harvard English Professor George Pierce Baker, author of the Dramatic Technique textbook of dramatic principles, co-founder of the Yale School of Drama, and leader of Harvard's 47 Workshop playwriting seminar, whose participants included George Abbott, S.N. Behrman, Ben Hecht, Sidney Howard, Eugene O'Neill, and Thomas Wolfe. At The Playboy's premiere, Baker enlisted students of his to report trouble from agitators protesting the play for its "indecency." Even so, the Abbey Theatre was a hit at the Plymouth.

The many world premieres and pre-Broadway tryouts at the Plymouth included 
Moss Hart & George S. Kaufman's The Man Who Came to Dinner; William Saroyan's The Time of Your Life; Paul Osborn's Morning's at Seven; Eugenia, based on Henry James' The Europeans, with Tallulah Bankhead; and Jean Anouilh and Lillian Hellman's The Lark, with Boris Karloff and Julie Harris. Boston Herald American theater critic Elliot Norton, known as a "play doctor" whose critiques of Boston tryout productions led to revisions that helped those plays and musicals succeed on Broadway, attended and critiqued many Plymouth presentations that went on to Broadway success, and called the theater "one of the crucibles of the American Drama." 
It was well designed for that role, with 1,500 seats, a horseshoe proscenium arch, an autumnal-shaded, softly-lit house, and a design that put audience and actors more intimately near each other.

Stars that took the stage at the Plymouth included Bill "Bojangles" Robinson, 8-year-old Sammy Davis Jr., Bette Davis, Paul Muni in Elmer Rice's Counselor at Law, Anthony Quinn (as Stanley Kowalski) and Uta Hagen (as Blanche DuBois) in Tennessee Williams' A Streetcar Named Desire, Alfred Lunt and Lynn Fontaine in S.N. Behrman's I Know My Love, Tallulah Bankhead and Marlon Brando in Jean Cocteau's Eagle Rampant (from which Brando was fired after one performance for playing a death scene more broadly than what the director wanted, though Bankhead recommended him to Elia Kazan for the part of Stanley Kowalski in A Streetcar Named Desire, which launched him to stardom), Rex Harrison in John van Druten's Bell, Book and Candle, Spencer Tracy in Robert E. Sherwood's The Rugged Path, Vivian Blaine of Guys and Dolls fame in Michael V. Gazzo's A Hatful of Rain, and, of course, Boris Karloff and Julie Harris in Jean Anouilh and Lillian Hellman's The Lark.

In 1957, sensing the erosion of the theater market by the movies, the Shuberts transferred the Plymouth to cinema entrepreneur Benjamin Sack, owner of the Sack Theatres chain, who gave it a facelift and a gut-rehab with a Todd-AO big screen and a stereophonic sound system as a state-of-the-art moviehouse called the Gary, named for his son.

For its new purpose its interior was stripped of its detail except for its proscenium arch, and its façade was transformed from the neoclassical arch of the dramatic arts to a sleek, chic green grill with a four-pronged neon star flashing across it, cantilevering a floating sign that vertically spelled out the new name in lit-up lozenge-shaped blocks 
so that it couldn't not be noticed. 

And draw crowds it did. The Gary became one of Boston's leading first-run "roadshow" moviehouses, premiering and long-running such legends as The Pride and the Passion, The Bridge on the River Kwai, Gigi, Can-Can, Lawrence of Arabia, The Sound of Music (which played for a record 83 weeks), a re-release of Gone with the Wind, and Earthquake, for which the Gary was retrofit in Sensurround, a sound system that activated giant subwoofers to virtually shake the seats and the balcony during the movie's devastation scenes, so the audience
could feel them while seeing them.
Photo from the Chris Davitt collection.
Of course, the Gary ws not immune to flops. For instance, Crossed Swords was a bad film. I saw it at the Radio City Music Hall in New York, only because I thought it would be my last chance to see the stellar theater and its high-kicking Rockettes before it closed (though it was later restored as the Radio City Music Hall Entertainment Center). The Rockettes were as stunning as legend had them, but I found the feature to be a slow-moving, uninspired remake of Errol Flynn's classic The Prince and the Pauper. This one had a star-studded cast to attempt to atone for its weak script and stodgy direction – Ernest Borgnine, Rex Harrison, David Hemmings, Charlton Heston, Oliver Reed, George C. Scott, Raquel Welch – with Mark Lester (who had played the lead in the movie musical Oliver! as a boy, with Oliver Reed as Bill Sikes) in his final film appearance, as both the prince and the pauper, roles he was clearly too old for, and clearly didn't like. He mumbled his part so much he could hardly be heard, an obvious sign that his enthusiasm for his career was on the wane. (Today he is an osteopath specializing in sports injuries.) (BTW, the Budweiser infomercial that preceded the movie, documenting the breeding of Clydesdale horses to transport the beer, was far more entertaining – sort of an extension of that "Here comes the king" commercial seen in Close Encounters.)

When plans for the State Transportation Building were announced, my father, Leslie Larson, summoned his City Conservation League preservationist coalition to send a rallying cry to save the Gary from destruction, convinced that the Plymouth's original façade lay hidden under the Gary's ultramodern skin (as the ornate parapet along its roofline hinted). He even attempted to generate interest in the cause from Elliot Norton, only to be met with, "Oh, I don't have time." (A surprising response from someone who called the Plymouth 
"one of the crucibles of the American Drama" and mentioned it eleven times in his 1978 book Broadway Down East.) The Boston Landmarks Commission confirmed Norton's indifference by unanimously voting down a landmark designation for the theatre "without discussion," in my father's words. (They also declined to landmark 12-16 Carver Street.) In other words, you can't fight City Hall; once the government is dead-set on seizing a site by eminent domain for a new Reichstag, there's no stopping it.

Jordan Marsh (1861-1880, Nathaniel Bradlee, Samuel J.F. Thayer).
My father's unsuccessful efforts to save it from demolition in 1975
 led to his organization of the City Conservation League, which in
turn inspired the formation of the Boston Landmarks Commission.
Old clichés, I know. But the tear-down tyrants of the '70s were caught up in old clichés themselves: the bulldozing of Boston for big government complexes (think Scollay Square and a chunk of Beacon Hill and the West End for Government Center) and the private-sector destruction of landmarks because they had supposedly outlasted their usefulness (Jordan Marsh department store in Downtown Crossing [right], St. Mary's Church in the North End). Never mind their artistry, their history, their visual beauty, their public favor. They're coming down. Period. End of discussion. This was what ignited my father's City Conservation League to preserve whole areas of Boston for their historical richness, since he knew too well that a few scattered landmarks hither and yon doth not a historic city make. It was necessary to conserve whole blocks, streets, districts and neighborhoods for citizens to taste Boston's full historical flavor, as had been done with Beacon Hill, the Back Bay, and the South End. His preservationist efforts inspired the creation of the Boston Landmarks Commission, which was very weak in the beginning, rejecting the designations of St. Mary's, the Plymouth/Gary, 12-16 Carver Street, and many other buildings overwhelmingly. 

So down went the Plymouth – and, sure enough, the old façade was revealed when the Gary's face fell with the wrecking ball. And the original proscenium arch got one last public exposure as well. This was another example of "urban renewal" at its worst: destroying intimate communities that attracted social and cultural deviants or people looking for something different, wiping out remnants of the residential and small-shop village Boston had been before the growth of its downtown encroached upon it, and replacement of it all with another sprawling, overbuilt modernist monstrosity that has attracted far fewer people over the years than the social and cultural institutions it forced out, owing in large part to its comparatively drab, forgettable architecture that will make me never forget what was there before.




Thank you for visiting. I welcome your comments!


Sources:

Bichajian, Nishan, "Courtyard of Ola's Restaurant, with Diners, Carver Street," MIT Libraries: Digital Collections, July 7, 1956, https://dome.mit.edu/entities/picture/52423c49-2c74-4bae-81ed-8be84a7f0329


Boston, Charles, "Once Upon A Time in Boston's Theatre District: The Story of the Plymouth Theatre...aka...the Gary," Charles Presents...The USA Retro Times, February 28, 2011, https://usaretrotimes.blogspot.com/2011/02/once-upon-time-in-bostons-theatre.html

Brooks, Rebecca Beatrice, "Union Oyster House: Oldest Restaurant in Boston," History of Massachusetts Blog, June 26, 2026, https://historyofmassachusetts.org/union-oyster-house-boston/

Colimon, Zoe, "Pride and Progress: A Journey Through Boston's LGBTQ+ Safe Spaces," Norman B. Leventhal Map & Education Center at the Boston Public Library, September 13, 2023, https://www.leventhalmap.org/articles/queer-boston/

Cross, Jonathan, and David Peterson (eds.), "The Gay Cruise-Aider," Gay Community News, Vol. 1, No. 42, April 13, 1974, https://digitalcommons.usm.maine.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?params=/context/gaycommunitynews/article/1041/&path_info=GCN_1_42_300ppi.pdf

DeLuca, Gerald A., "Gary Theatre," Cinema Treasures, 2015, https://cinematreasures.org/theaters/6415

"Edgar Allan Poe Birthplace // c.1805-1965," Buildings of New England, February 10, 2025, https://buildingsofnewengland.com/2025/02/10/edgar-allen-poe-birthplace-c-1805-1965/

"Elliot Norton," Wikipedia, last edited on 1 September 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elliot_Norton

Erickson, Scott, "Herbie's Ramrod Room and 12 Carver Bar in Boston's Gay History," GayBarchives, Facebook, March 10, 2025, https://www.facebook.com/groups/gaybarchives/posts/2399316767079702/

"Gary Theatre," CinemaTour, last edited August 20, 2018, https://www.cinematour.com/tour/us/23419.html

"George Pierce Baker," Wikipedia, last edited on 15 August 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_Pierce_Baker

Harris, John Adams, "Herbie's Ram-Rod Room in 1975 | Boston, MA," Vintage American Bars, Lounges, Clubs, Taverns & Saloons, Facebook, February 18, 2026, https://www.facebook.com/groups/849009033875173/posts/1230536659055740/

"Hillbilly Ranch," Wikipedia, last edited on 16 September 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hillbilly_Ranch

Iyer, Neil (author), and Grace Clipson (editor), "Scollay Square," The West End Museum, 2021, https://thewestendmuseum.org/history/era/immigrant-neighborhood/scollay-square/

Keating, Tom, "How many of you saw a movie at the Gary theater and what movie was it?", Metro Boston Memories, History and News, Facebook, April 12, 2020, https://www.facebook.com/groups/859140650954255/posts/1340878932780422/
 

Labbe, Izzy, "Tracing Queer History in Boston," Boston Preservation Alliance, June 25, 2019, https://www.bostonpreservation.org/news-item/tracing-queer-history-boston

"Mark Lester," Wikipedia, last edited on 31 July 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mark_Lester

Merry, George B., "State transportation building may be the right structure in wrong place," The Christian Science Monitor, December 8, 1983, https://www.csmonitor.com/1983/1208/120856.html


Morgan, Keith N., "State Transportation Building," Massachusetts, Society of Architectural Historians Archipedia, eds. Gabrielle Esperdy and Karen Kingsly, Charlottesville: UVaP, 2012—, https://sah-archipedia.org/node/14207

"1950s Gay Boston," Boston Queer History, November 21, 2014, https://markthomaskrone.wordpress.com/tag/12-carver-street/

Norton, Elliot, Broadway Down East: An Informal Account of the Plays, Players, and Playhouses of Boston from Puritan Times to the Present, Boston: Trustees of the Public Library of the City of Boston, 1978, https://archive.org/details/broadwaydowneast0000nort/page/n9/mode/2up

Nowlin, Bill, "Origins of Bluegrass in Boston," Boston Bluegrass Union, 2026, https://bbu.org/archives-bbu-history/origins-bluegrass-boston/

"Ola, behind the iron gate, 14 Carver Street, Boston, Mass., undated," Historic New England, 2007, https://www.historicnewengland.org/explore/collections-access/gusn/248996

Osinski, Stan, "Edgar Allan Poe's birthplace in Boston," Boston Mass, Vintage, Facebook, September 15, 2024, https://www.facebook.com/groups/513744017561133/posts/737050391897160/

Penn, Evan, and Martin Pilataxi Barrera, "A Queer History of Boston," Northeastern University Library: Cities, Landscape, and Modern Culture, https://landscapes.northeastern.edu/a-queer-history-of-boston-evan-penn-martin-pilataxi-barrera/

"Plymouth Theatre," Wikipedia, last edited on 3 July 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plymouth_Theatre_(Boston)

"Plymouth Theatre (Boston) facts for kids," Kiddle Encyclopedia, last modified on 17 October 2025, https://kids.kiddle.co/Plymouth_Theatre_(Boston)

Rocheleau, Matt, "All of Boston’s historic landmarks, and the ones that failed to make the cut," The Boston Globe, March 17, 2017, https://www.bostonglobe.com/metro/2017/03/17/all-boston-historic-landmarks-and-ones-that-failed-make-cut/BExHEExQIzWaGDTOAL9l5O/story.html?event=event12

Rocheleau, Matt, and Nicole Dungca, "Emerson eyes state Transportation Building," The Boston Globe, November 13, 2014, https://www.bostonglobe.com/metro/2014/11/13/transportation-building-holds-interest-for-emerson/0INo9TzVu2YYLViv64lkTN/story.html

Smith, Dana, "Historic Broadway and Carver Street in Boston, MA's Bay Village neighborhood," Boston Mass, Vintage, Facebook, July 2, 2026, https://www.facebook.com/groups/513744017561133/posts/1198623485739846/

"Social Settlements: United States, Massachusetts, Boston, Ellis Memorial and Eldridge House," Harvard Art Museums, 2011, https://harvardartmuseums.org/collections/object/313631

"State Transportation Building," Deep Excavation, 1981-1982, https://www.deepexcavation.com/post/state-transportation-building-boston-ma

"Stonewall riots," Wikipedia, last edited on 6 October 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stonewall_riots

Storia, Sir, "Hillbilly Ranch: A legendary Boston country music hall that defined New England's western sound for four decades," Sir Storia, June 11, 2026, https://sirstoria.com/locations/massachusetts/boston/hillbilly-ranch

Strahan, Derek, "Edgar Allan Poe Birthplace, Boston," Lost New England, March 14, 2023, https://lostnewengland.com/2023/03/edgar-allan-poe-birthplace-boston/


Trahan, Erin, "With Another New Movie Theater, A Look At Boston’s Moviegoing Past And Future," WBUR, December 19, 2019, https://www.wbur.org/news/2019/12/19/boston-movie-theater-arclight

"Testimonies/Stories about the Twelve Carver Bar in Boston," r/lgbthistory, Reddit, January 2026, https://www.reddit.com/r/lgbthistory/comments/1pfxn95/testimoniesstories_about_the_twelve_carver_bar_in/

"The Lark (play)," Wikipedia, last edited on 3 June 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Lark_(play)

Turner, Mark, "Places, Music Business: Hillbilly Ranch," Music Museum of New England, April 15, 2025, https://www.mmone.org/hillbilly-ranch/


Whitcomb, Robert, "Remembering Hillbilly Ranch," New England Diary, May 1 (n.d.), https://www.newenglanddiary.com/blog/2025/5/1/gbcewo77yaeggyu9ru77bc8wicjfsm

Yudis, Anthony J., "State transportation building: A little something for almost everyone," The Boston Globe, September 7, 1980.

No comments:

Post a Comment