Saturday, November 21, 2026

Over-restoration, Part I

View from The Lawn to the Rotunda at the University of Virginia. Photo by Karen Blaha.
Rotunda on fire, 1895.
When the University of Virginia's Rotunda (1828) was restored to Thomas Jefferson's original design to celebrate the 1976 American Revolution Bicentennial (and sesquicentennial of Jefferson's death, which happened to be July 4, 1826, when his frenemy John Adams passed away too) fifty years ago, the American Institute of Architects called Jefferson's Rotunda, Lawn, and Monticello "the proudest achievement of American architecture in the past 200 years."

They would have had more to be proud of had they let well enough alone in the Rotunda.

The Rotunda's Dome Room as a library before its restoration.
Following the 1895 fire that gutted the Rotunda, Stanford White of McKim, Mead & White redesigned its interior in a style that was not Jefferson's, but was very compatible, and in line with the neoclassical City Beautiful movement that had been exhibited with pomp and splendor at the World Columbian Exposition in Chicago two years prior. In this way the new design added new dimensions to the Dome Room.

The Dome Room's midway dividing floor was removed to create one soaring space, supported by a circle of 20 evenly spaced monumental Corinthian columns paralleling those on Jefferson's portico. To stimulate rigorous study and scholastic success, the ribboned wreath, a Grecian symbol of honor and glory, was mounted on the cast-iron balconies and in-between names of literati – Plato, Horace, Molière, Poe, Homer, Bacon, Tacitus, Milton, Pindar, Cicero, etc. – on the frieze. Crowning this was the lace collar of "Union Jack" grill rails common in neoclassicism, here as a circular balcony.

A ball in the Dome Room of the Rotunda, shortly before its restoration.
The architects also rearranged the space with two mezzanines to better house and organize the university's ever-expanding book collection, create study spaces by windows, and designate the Dome Room's main floor as a general study area. Smartly, the interior was rebuilt in fireproof materials, including Rafael Guastavino's clay tile ceiling vaulting.

1876 drawing of the Rotunda by W.G.R. Frayser. University of Virginia Library.
In this way, White seized the opportunity the fire presented to redesign the Dome Room for the unversity library's contemporary needs, while restraining it within the classical vocabulary Jefferson had established for it. This union of Jeffersonian and functionalist Classicism proved the timelessness of the style's ability to meet academic requirements throughout the generations.

Rotunda restoration, mid-1970s.
Momentum grew in the 1950s to bring Jefferson's vision back to the Rotunda, and 
Prof. Frederick D. Nichols of the University of Virginia School of Architecture conferred with the university's Buildings and Grounds Committee on the best way to “correct the alterations." Richmond architects Ballou & Justice were retained to do the honors; they recommended an overhaul of the interior. The U.S. Bicentennial Committee urged the Rotunda restoration to be of prime concern for the Bicentennial, and a HUD grant for it was secured to match the private donations. As expected, the interior was gutted and returned to Jefferson's concept of the mid-level floor creating two Dome Room spaces, the upper one encircled by 20 pairs of composite wood columns concealing bookcases and stairs. The roof was replaced in white-painted galvanized steel, and its rooftop skylight oculus was altered to the size and sunburst design of Jefferson's.

The restored Dome Room, Rotunda, UVA. Photo by Alex Proimos.
I had the privilege of paying a visit to the Rotunda when its restoration was in progress in the summer of '76, and I found its "fake Jefferson" job to be a bit much. The all-new columns, balustrade, and turned-baluster stairs looked more like a modern Georgian Revival mansion than honest exhibitions of Jefferson's craftsmanship.

Columns, Rotunda Dome Room. Photo: Karen Blaha.
A further restoration in 2016 recreated the original composite-capital columns. Richmond craftsman Christopher Hildebrand closely followed the original scheme of Jefferson's craftsman Philip Sturtevant, who had followed 
Giacomo Leoni’s 1715 edition of Andrea Palladio’s The Four Books of Architecture depicting the five classical orders of columns as a historical resource for his work. Hildebrand carved his columns in African mahogany, which was selected for its density, instead of the old-growth white pine Sturtevant used, because today's pine was deemed too soft. A sound-absorbing plaster ceiling replicating the original was installed as well. “We’re working from photographs, drawings and different source documents,” Hildebrand said. "Every part relates to one another. This is the hardest thing we have ever worked on.” And one of the costliest; $200,000 was spent on new equipment to replicate the old-world craftsmanship, UVA Today reported.

Columns, bookcase and stairs in Dome Room of Rotunda. Photo by T.G. Hess.
"Our main goal was to respect the many layers of history in the building," said Jody Lahendro, UVA's s historic preservation architect. Well, more layers of history would have been respected had Stanford White's layer been preserved as an historic interior in its own right, reflecting the Rotunda's evolution according to changes in the UVA library's social, spatial and academic needs.

Thomas Jefferson's Monticello, Charlottesville, VA. Photo: Martin Falbisoner.
The
 "restored" Rotunda will fool future generations into thinking its columns, banisters, ceiling and floor are all Jefferson's originals. For a true Jefferson original, all they need to do is visit Monticello down the road in Charlottesville.

More to come...

Sources:

Afzal, Fahrat, "Reviving The Revere House: An Architectural Viewpoint on the Home’s Restoration," PaulRevereHouse.org, January 20, 2026, https://www.paulreverehouse.org/reviving-the-revere-house-an-architectural-viewpoint-on-the-homes-restoration/

Cusack, Andrew, "The Perils of Over-Restoration," Andrew Cusack, May 24, 2006, https://www.andrewcusack.com/2006/the-perils-of-over-restoration/

Kelly, Matt, "Nearly Completed Renovations Restore Dome Room’s Original Touches," UVA Today, June 24, 2016, https://archive.news.virginia.edu/content/nearly-completed-renovations-restore-dome-rooms-original-touches/

"Louisiana State Bank Building," Wikipedia, last edited on 6 September 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Louisiana_State_Bank_Building

McCance, McGregor, "Rector Reaffirms UVA’s Institutional Connection to Thomas Jefferson," UVA Today, September 16, 2022, https://news.virginia.edu/content/rector-reaffirms-uvas-institutional-connection-thomas-jefferson

"Paul Revere House," Wikipedia,  last edited on 2 October 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paul_Revere_House

Rettig, Polly M., "National Register of Historic Places Inventory – Nomination Form: Paul Revere House," United States Department of the Interior National Park Service, December 8, 1975, https://www.npshistory.com/publications/bost/nr-paul-revere-house.pdf

"Rotunda, University of Virginia," Virginia Department of Historic Resources, updated February 28, 2024, https://www.dhr.virginia.gov/historic-registers/002-5055/

"The Neoclassical Beauty of Thomas Jefferson's Rotunda at UVA," Early American Architecture, Art, and Other Obsessions, Facebook, September 17, 2026, https://www.facebook.com/groups/157104191579343/posts/2159402164682859/

"The Paul Revere House," The Paul Revere Memorial Association, https://www.paulreverehouse.org/mission-history/

"The Rotunda: Did You Know?", University of Virginia, https://rotunda.virginia.edu/did-you-know

"The Rotunda: History," University of Virginia, https://rotunda.virginia.edu/history

"The Rotunda," University of Virginia, https://rotunda.virginia.edu/ 

"The Rotunda (University of Virginia)," Wikipedia,  last edited on 20 October 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Rotunda_(University_of_Virginia)

Walser, Lauren, "Thomas Jefferson's Rotunda Receives An A-Plus Renovation," Preservation Magazine, Winter 2017, https://savingplaces.org/stories/thomas-jefferson-rotunda-renovation

Wilson, Richard Guy, "Rotunda," Society of Architectural Historians Archipedia, https://sah-archipedia.org/buildings/VA-01-CH28.1

No comments:

Post a Comment